In divorces involving military personnel, the Armed Forces pension (the AFPS) is one of the most valuable assets. Indeed, it is often the most valuable asset. There are three main armed forces pension schemes – the AFPS 1975, the AFPS 2005 and the AFPS 2015.

It is critical that early advice is taken in respect of both the structure of the schemes and the rights held within them. For military pension scheme members, there may be an entitlement to both an immediate pension (at the point of leaving the forces provided the requisite number of years’ service has been reached) and also a preserved or deferred pension, which is payable at normal retirement age or state pension age, depending on the scheme in which pension benefits are held.

Military veterans may also receive or be entitled to additional pension benefits if they retired early as a result of injury or early departure payments. Some of these benefits also attract different tax treatment as well.

Typically, pensions can be shared via a pension sharing order, pension attachment order or by off-setting but given the nuances of the AFPS, thought must be given to how pension claims of both the non-serving and the member spouse can be settled.

What are the main differences between pension sharing and off-setting?

A pension sharing order made over a military pension scheme requires Veterans UK, who administer all armed forces schemes, to deduct from the member spouse’s pension a percentage of the value of that pension. That “slice” of pension is then transferred as a credit into a new pension in the name of the non-member spouse, who then becomes a member of the AFPS. Not all pensions allow internal transfers but the AFPS do. This is a completely separate pension, which is moved at the point of divorce, rather than retirement, and then drawn upon when that spouse reaches retirement age. This means that pension sharing does not impact the ability to achieve a clean break, if that is the joint objective.

It is important to understand that a pension sharing order can only be obtained with a divorce – it is not possible to obtain a pension sharing order without a financial order covering the overall financial settlement and a final order in the divorce which dissolves the marriage.

Pension sharing is appropriate (and often preferable) when parties are trying to achieve a fair outcome both in relation to the “here and now”, but also forecasting ahead to retirement. The court also prefers to endorse agreements where parties are sharing a mix of capital and pension assets as part of the overall settlement.

Pension off-setting is an alternative method of notionally sharing pension assets by balancing the value of one party’s pension benefits against other capital/property assets held between spouses. In practice this means that one party to the negotiations can elect to retain a greater proportion of the capital in lieu of their claims upon a spouse’s pension. In order to calculate the off-set value, an actuary or PODE (Pensions Expert on Divorce) will need to be instructed because pensions and capital/cash are different asset classes and therefore, cannot be valued on a like-for-like basis. In other words, £1 of pension is not equivalent to £1 of cash.

How are military pension schemes structured?

There are three main pension schemes under the umbrella of the Armed Forces Pension Scheme and membership of each scheme depends on when the service member was operational.

The AFPS 1975

Scheme Dates: 1975 to 5 April 2005.

Normal Retirement Age: age 55 but an Immediate Pension is available after 16 or 22 years depending on rank held. A Deferred Pension can also be paid for those who do not have the requisite years of service for an Immediate Pension from age 60 or 65 depending on when service took place. Early departure payments are not payable under this scheme.

The AFPS 2005

Scheme Dates: 6 April 2005 to 31 March 2015. 

Normal Retirement Age: age 55 (and is also the Immediate Pension point) and a Deferred Pension can also be paid for those who do not have the requisite years of service from age 65. Early departure payments are available under this scheme after 18 years’ service and reaching at least age 40.

The AFPS 2015

Scheme Dates: 1 April 2015 to present.

Normal Retirement Age: age 60 (and is also the Immediate Pension point) and a Deferred Pension can also be paid for those who do not have the requisite years of service from State Pension age. Early departure payments are available after 20 years’ service and reaching at least age 40.

It is important to understand that early departure payments, whilst they derive from membership to a particular pension scheme, are not classed as a pension benefit and cannot be shared under a pension sharing order. Early advice should therefore be taken to ensure that they are properly taken into account as part of the wider settlement.

What factors do courts consider when dealing with military pensions on divorce?

The valuations of military pensions are calculated based on the rate of pay at the time of retirement or final pensionable earnings (AFPS 1975), earnings received over the final three years of service (AFPS 2005) or annual earnings each year (AFPS 2015). Pension lump sums are payable of up to 25% of the total pension benefits under the 1975 and 2005 schemes but under the 2015 scheme, a lump sum is only payable if the pension member commutes some of their pension to create a lump sum.

When considering sharing or off-setting military pensions, the court will look at the parties’ respective ages, the length of the marriage and when the pension benefits were accrued. These factors inform whether a pension sharing order is to be made in order to provide spouses with equal incomes on retirement, or whether there should be a departure from that on account of:

  1. pre- or post-marital accrual
  2. differences in parties’ needs, such as if there is an age gap between them
  3. consideration of how and why a military pension is in payment, such as if the service member was injured during service and therefore compensates for a career being cut short.
  4. Oversight of when pension benefits can be accessed and whether substantive spousal maintenance or a deferred pension sharing order should be considered to plug any gap.

How can you decide which approach is right for you?

In all likelihood, both legal and actuarial advice is going to be required when considering either sharing or off-setting a military pension. This is because they are defined benefit schemes which firstly, often hold significant value, not all of which is always represented in the CEV (Cash Equivalent Valuation). Secondly, it is not unusual to encounter a number of nuances typical of these schemes, to include early departure payments and non-shareable pension benefits which may have been awarded or accrued on account of early medical retirement.

In conjunction with expert input, we can help and advise you on the different approaches that can be taken to pension sharing and pension off-setting in respect of AFPS schemes. The earlier you take advice on that issue, the better. An up to date CEV, together with any commutation details and a breakdown of pension accrual are good starting points to enable us then to look at the bigger picture and options that may be available.